Federal judge vacates new visa restrictions for students and journalists
A Massachusetts federal court has ruled against the Trump administration's attempt to impose strict time limits on nonimmigrant visas, preserving the ability of international students and foreign press members to stay in the US based on their status.
By Lorenzo Evans ·

A US federal judge has invalidated the Trump administration's recent effort to limit the duration of visas for international students and members of the foreign press. The decision, issued by Massachusetts District Judge Dennis Saylor on Monday, comes after university and media unions challenged the Department of Homeland Security in a lawsuit filed in August.
Saylor determined that the government failed to demonstrate widespread visa fraud or specific national security concerns justifying the changes to the visa program. In his written decision, the judge described the administration's move as arbitrary and capricious. He noted that the department was effectively trying to discourage the very activities that Congress intended to encourage, such as providing educational opportunities for foreign nationals.
The ruling preserves the duration of status, commonly referred to as the D/S stamp, which is found on F, J, and I visas. These are nonimmigrant categories that do not lead to permanent residency or citizenship. Under the previous system, individuals in these categories could legally remain in the country for as long as they maintained their specific status, whether as active students or working journalists, regardless of whether that period lasted months or years.
The proposed changes would have significantly curtailed these periods of stay. Students would have been restricted to a maximum of four years, while journalists would have been limited to eight months. The administration first proposed these strict time limits more than a year ago and opened a public comment period. The department received approximately 22,000 comments, the vast majority of which opposed the proposed changes.
Despite the public feedback, the Department of Homeland Security proceeded to impose the new restrictions in July, allowing only a 60-day window before they took effect. In response, a coalition of groups including NAFSA, the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, and several labor unions filed a legal complaint demanding an injunction to stop the rule from taking effect.
Support for the legal challenge also came from the journalism sector. More than 30 free speech advocacy organizations, including Pen America and the Society of Professional Journalists, signed a letter urging Congress to block the rule by withholding funds for the department if necessary. The letter argued that the US was joining the ranks of repressive governments in using visa processes to punish reporters.
Judge Saylor issued a temporary injunction on September 14, just seven hours before the new rules were scheduled to go into effect. This week's final decision ends the case in its current form, though the administration retains the right to appeal. The ruling has been welcomed by key stakeholders in both education and media.
Robert J McCarron, president and CEO of the Association of Independent Colleges & Universities in Massachusetts, stated that international students contribute significantly to campus vibrancy and economic vitality. Meanwhile, the Committee to Protect Journalists described the decision as exceptional relief. Jose Zamora, the organization's regional director for the Americas, explained that requiring journalists to reapply for extensions every 240 days would have created an undue burden, especially given the administration's scrutiny of media coverage.
The Foreign Press Association expressed pleasure with the outcome but urged caution. President Ian Williams noted that while the legal victory is significant, bureaucratic practices in visa issuance might not fully reflect the spirit of the judgment. He warned that deep prejudice motivated the administration's moves and advised media professionals to prepare carefully for travel.
In 2024, approximately 37,000 foreign journalists were admitted to the US on I-Visas. These individuals are permitted to work only for international news organizations headquartered overseas. Major outlets such as Reuters, the BBC, Sky News, and Al Jazeera would have been heavily impacted by the proposed restrictions. The system allows these journalists to remain in the country for extended periods to build trusted sources and provide nuanced coverage of US politics and culture.






