AdvertiseDonate
LatestThree Arab men shot dead in Israel within a single day
Fri, Nov 20, 2026Los AngelesNew YorkChicagoHoustonPhoenixPhiladelphiaSan FranciscoSeattleAtlantaBoston
Worldwide Herald · 40 W 2nd St, 2nd Floor, Dayton, OH 45402

Coronial inquest finds missed routine checks contributed to deaths of four NSW infants

A coronial inquest in New South Wales has heard that four infants who died between 2022 and 2024 might have survived if standard medical monitoring and follow-up care had been provided.

By Lorenzo Evans ·

Illustration for: Coronial inquest finds missed routine checks contributed to deaths of four NSW infants
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A coronial inquest in Lismore has heard that four babies who died in the northern rivers region of New South Wales between 2022 and 2024 might have survived with routine checks and appropriate medical follow-up. The cases involve Baby DH, Baby D, Baby R, and Baby B, all of whom were born through free or home birth arrangements. Evidence presented to the court suggests that factors such as traumatic past experiences, a lack of trust in medical professionals, and limited access to services influenced the mothers' decisions to avoid clinical settings.

Baby DH died approximately eight hours after being born in a free birth attended by a doula but no medical professionals. The infant turned purple, struggled to breathe, and became floppy. His parents testified that they were concerned, yet the doula repeatedly reassured them that the baby was fine before eventually leaving. The doula later denied providing clinical advice and disputed several of the parents' claims. Expert neonatologist Associate Professor Nicholas Evans stated that the infant's complex heart abnormalities would have been readily detectable during a routine pregnancy scan. Such a detection would have led to a referral to a paediatric cardiologist, which Evans described as a missed opportunity.

Paediatric cardiologist Dr Paul Brooks agreed that it was highly likely all abnormalities would have been identified prenatally. He noted that even if the full extent of the issues was not clear, a scan would have indicated the need for delivery at a major hospital with cardiac surgery capabilities. Dr Brooks told the court that the specific location of the birth meant Baby DH did not have a chance of survival without that specialized care.

The death of Baby D involved a complicated twin pregnancy. The mother was unaware she was carrying twins and initially mistook the placenta of the first baby for the delivery of the second, who was stillborn. While experts discussed the possibility that the birth keeper did not clamp the umbilical cord before cutting it, Associate Professor Evans concluded the most likely cause of death was respiratory distress due to compromised heart function. He stated that advanced resuscitation within ten minutes might have saved the infant, but the root cause was the undiagnosed twin pregnancy. Had the twins been identified at 18 weeks, standard practice would have included close monitoring.

Baby R died from severe post-maturity after being born at 43 weeks and one day in a free birth. Standard medical practice dictates inducing birth or performing a caesarean section at 42 weeks to protect against risks associated with an aging placenta. The mother had received an ultrasound at 12 weeks that set a due date of 28 July 2020. However, she trusted her birth keeper, Sita Tara Kali, over hospital advice. Kali advised recalculating the due date based on conception, an unreliable method that pushed the expected delivery to mid-August. Evans identified this recalculation as the root cause of the delay.

An ultrasound on 19 August indicated the pregnancy had become a medical emergency. Despite this, Kali advised the mother to go home and rest. Evans told the court it was more likely than not that the baby would have survived if the mother had gone to hospital following that scan. Expert midwives noted that babies born beyond 43 weeks are rare, making specific statistics difficult to establish.

Baby B was born via home birth after the mother was repeatedly warned to deliver her twins in a hospital. Four midwives assisted in the birth, and the head midwife counselled the mother on the risks. The mother declined ultrasounds and a test for group B streptococcus, an organism found in 15 to 20 percent of women that can infect about 2 percent of their babies. Evans stated that Baby B likely died from GBS, pneumonia, and sepsis, while his twin survived after falling ill. He noted that many infected babies survive in hospital settings where antibiotics are available.

The inquest into these four deaths remains ongoing as the court continues to examine the circumstances surrounding each case.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Worldwide Herald in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Worldwide Herald in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.