Asylum seekers on final 'one in, one out' UK-France flight say they feel 'punished'
Many of those due to be removed on the last flight under the UK-France returns pilot are people who crossed back to Britain after fleeing violence and exploitation by smugglers in France.
By Khalid Khalil ·

Many of the asylum seekers due to board Tuesday's final deportation flight under the UK's 'one in, one out' arrangement with France are people who returned to Britain after already being forcibly removed, saying they fled threats and violence from people smugglers.
Hundreds of those sent back to France are thought to have made their way back to the UK. Several told the Guardian that smugglers pursued them, claiming their families still owed money for the Channel crossing. They described being punched, beaten or raped, and some said they were caught while sleeping on the streets and forced to work in conditions of modern slavery in a migrant camp in Calais, cleaning the smugglers' tents and carrying water or firewood.
The pilot scheme involved forcibly returning hundreds of people who had travelled to the UK on small boats to France, in exchange for a similar number being brought from northern France to claim asylum in Britain. The arrangement ended on 1 October, and the charity Medical Justice, which has supported people detained under it, called it 'a disaster'.
One Iranian man with a ticket for Tuesday's flight said smugglers captured him after the Home Office returned him to France earlier this year. He said he was a political dissident in Iran and believed he would be executed if sent back there. 'I came back to the UK a second time because the smugglers caught me in France,' he said, adding that he slept on the streets of Paris because France did not accept his asylum case. 'Many of the people who have tickets for Tuesday's flight are people like me, who came back to the UK a second time. I believe those of us who came back to the UK a second time are being punished by being sent back to France a second time. I believe that 100%.'
He said that although the Home Office stated that sufficient lawyers were available for those detained for removal to France, he and others struggled to access good quality legal advice. Friends paid privately for a lawyer who promised to challenge his removal 24 hours before the flight but 'has done nothing' and no longer answers the phone, he said. 'My mind is broken. I am scared that when I am returned to France on Tuesday, the smugglers will catch me and kill me.' He added that when guards came to take him to the plane last time, three or four of them surrounded him and made him feel like a criminal, and that with the weather now too cold to sleep outside, he does not know what he will do.
A second asylum seeker due to fly on Tuesday, who also returned to the UK after being sent back to France, said he knew of dozens of people in the same position. 'All of us have bad solicitors who are not helping us,' he said. 'One in, one out finished on 1 October. I do not understand why the Home Office wants to continue sending us to France.'
John Tuckett, the independent chief inspector of borders and immigration, said in a report published last week that it was not known how the Home Office would measure the scheme's success or failure, despite it being given the highest operational priority, with regular updates supplied to ministers and 10 Downing Street. He cited a ministerial submission stating that the aim was to demonstrate that dangerous small boat journeys were not a viable option for entry into the UK and to undermine the organised immigration crime model. Since the scheme ended, 4,786 people have crossed the Channel in 69 small boats, according to government data.
A Medical Justice spokesperson said: 'One in, one out has been a disaster, causing avoidable suffering to a vulnerable group and it has failed in the Home Office's stated objective. The Home Office must start to learn lessons and put an end to dangerous detention conditions.' Seema Syeda, of the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants, said the government had forced people fleeing war, climate breakdown and persecution to take 'murderous and traumatising journeys' across the Channel, 'only to treat them with brutality once they have arrived here, retraumatising them with detention and deportation.'
A Home Office spokesperson said: 'We welcome the inspector's recognition of the strong operational delivery of the UK-France pilot, which successfully demonstrated that a returns arrangement of this kind can work. The message was clear: if you returned to the UK after being transferred to France under the pilot, you would be sent back.' The spokesperson added that the pilot had now concluded, that lessons learned were being taken forward as part of wider efforts to strengthen returns, and that any future operational decisions, including on evaluation and reporting, would be considered in the usual way.






